Faith, Chaos, and Negligence
- Naysha Kasat
- Feb 20
- 3 min read
Faith and devotion turned into panic and despair as a massive stampede at the Maha Kumbh in Prayagraj claimed at least 30 lives and left over 60 injured. The incident occurred in the early hours of January 29, 2025. Also being an extremely important and auspicious day, this raises urgent concerns about the failure of crowd management at one of the world’s largest religious gatherings. With an estimated 400 million people expected to visit over 45 days, was this disaster inevitable, or a failure of planning?
Held once in 144 years, the Maha Kumbh is a very special gathering celebrated by the Hindus. It is a pilgrimage where millions gather to take a dip in the sacred rivers, believing that it will cleanse them of their sins. Prayagraj (formerly known as Allahabad), at the confluence of the Ganga, Yamuna, and mythical Saraswati rivers, hosts the event. The Amavasya (full moon) bath, is considered one of the most auspicious days and draws the largest crowds.
The disaster began around 1:30 AM when an influx of pilgrims pushed toward the main bathing ghats. Multiple pontoon bridges had been set up for crowd control, yet authorities suddenly rerouted a large number of devotees through a single, much narrower pathway. In no time the pathway became overcrowded. Panic spread, causing people to stumble and fall, turning the already precarious situation into a stampede. Survivors recall the horror of being crushed underfoot, unable to move or breathe.
The chaos was exacerbated by last-minute road closures, reportedly (though not confirmed) due to the presence of Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister, Yogi Adityanath in the vicinity. Security measures for VIPs led to crucial pathways being blocked, forcing authorities to reroute the large crowd in a way that increased congestion. This is an important reminder that the prioritization of political figures over the safety of ordinary citizens can have devastating consequences.
However, this is not the first time a Kumbh Mela has witnessed such a catastrophe. In 2013, a stampede at the Allahabad railway station killed 36 people, exposing the festival’s chronic mismanagement. Despite repeated assurances, crowd control failures persist. The 2025 Maha Kumbh Mela had a staggering ₹6,400 crore budget, yet basic crowd management failed at a critical moment. This raises a crucial question: If an event of this magnitude is planned years in advance, why do the same mistakes keep happening?
Prime Minister Narendra Modi expressed grief over the tragedy, saying, “My deepest condolences to the devotees who have lost their loved ones in this. Along with this, I wish for the speedy recovery of all the injured.” Chief Minister, Yogi Adityanath in response urged people to take a bath in their nearest ghats instead of going to the Sangam Nose.
The opposition was quick to criticize the government’s mismanagement. Rahul Gandhi blamed the “VIP culture” for this incident. They also criticized the government for allegedly hiding the total death count which added to the chaos, where people assumed that thousands were dead. The authorities blame the sheer volume of devotees, while critics point to the mismanagement of crowd control and poor planning.
At what point does a predictable disaster become an avoidable one? When over 30 people die in a preventable tragedy, it is not simply an unfortunate accident—it is a failure of responsibility. The death toll is not just a number; it represents families torn apart, dreams shattered, and faith tested.
With more auspicious days approaching which is expected to draw millions more—there is mounting pressure on the government to ensure better safety measures. Some experts suggest the introduction of AI-based crowd monitoring and stricter adherence to safety protocols. Others argue that cultural shifts are needed to prioritize pilgrim safety over political showmanship.
The Maha Kumbh has deep spiritual traditions, but it should not become a recurring symbol of tragedy. If meaningful reforms are not implemented, another tragedy is inevitable.
Picture:
